It is now well over 10 years since EA
Technology began studies to examine the feasibility of micro CHP. Initially the
efforts of technology developers were focused on overcoming the fundamental
engineering challenges, such as achieving extended operating hours without
service intervention. Further development work addressed the reliability of
ancillary components as well as the practicalities of manufacture at a realistic
cost. A number of micro CHP products are now at a stage where they face perhaps
the most significant challenge of all - that of fulfilling the demands of
domestic consumers.
All too often this has been the undoing of
novel technologies; witness the failure of heat pumps and condensing boilers to
achieve significant market penetration. If micro CHP is to fulfil its potential
for energy savings, environmental benefits and economic advantage, we need to be
absolutely confident that initial products will perform adequately and, equally
importantly, that they will be perceived in a positive light by potential
customers. It is for this reason that field trials of the WhisperTech unit have
been undertaken in UK homes over the past three years. Objective, independent
evaluation of performance by EA Technology has led to recommendations for
improvements, which have been incorporated into the evolving product at each
stage. This has resulted in a product which now appears to meet the requirements
for a target market sector comprising homes with sufficient energy bills to
provide the savings necessary to recover the initial investment.
During the 2002-2003 heating season, trials of
30 units were undertaken in a range of homes in the Chester and Ipswich areas.
The objective of this trial was to gain further installation and operating
experience of micro CHP and to identify an appropriate market sector for the
initial commercial launch.
This paper describes the installation and
performance of a micro CHP system in one of these trial homes. The system was
installed as a replacement for the existing gas boiler in a conventional
gas-fired central heating system and achieved energy savings in line with
expectations. Based on a total energy bill of £1000 per annum (£550 gas, £450
electricity) total savings of around £200 were projected for the whole year’s
operation. Subjective criteria such as noise and physical size and appearance
were viewed positively by all the trialists, although it was generally felt that
the micro CHP unit should be placed in a utility room, rather than kitchen area.
Although the system operated satisfactorily, a
major area of concern remains the reliability of any new product and early
failures could prove extremely damaging to the entire industry. It is for this
reason that initial units are equipped with remote diagnostics which alert the
service provider (in this case the manufacturer) if the unit is operating
outside normal parameters. This allows pre-emptive service before a fault occurs
and proved most effective in providing customer confidence in the systems.
Of the trialists responding to customer
satisfaction surveys, around 80% expressed a desire to retain the system after
the completion of the trial, although some are unable to do so for practical
reasons.
Following the successful outcome of this
trial, a cautious market launch is being proposed with 400 units being installed
in a clearly targeted market sector during the latter part of 2003. It is
expected that the units will be installed in larger, new family homes in
conjunction with a thermal store. This configuration is intended to enhance the
performance of the unit and provide a well designed package of compatible
components, hopefully overcoming some of the installation shortcomings
identified in existing homes. As this market becomes established, alternative
configurations are expected to be applied to other market sectors including the
numerous existing homes in which micro CHP can make a substantial impact.
FULL PAPER
|